They called it a national emergency. In 2021 the Biden White House declared that a “crisis of disinformation and misinformation” streaming through social media was fueling extreme polarization that could tip into domestic terrorism. Officials messaged platforms and suggested that failing to remove or throttle certain speech might lead to violence.
Then came the short-lived Disinformation Governance Board under Nina Jankowicz, the public face of an operation that collapsed under ridicule in May 2022. The whole project rested on a claim that has now been tested for four years by the Privacy and Civil Liberties Oversight Board. The result is damning. PCLOB received no evidence that disinformation actually fueled domestic terrorism.